religiones del Mediterráneo

El mar de todos los dioses25 enero, 2005

Primer capítulo de la serie, producida por la Diputación de Cádiz, El mar de la libertad, en el que se hace un repaso de las civilizaciones que construyeron imperios en torno al Mediterráneo —como los fenicios, los egipcios, los griegos o los romanos—, y sobre todo de las tres religiones monoteístas que surgieron en sus orillas: el judaísmo, el islamismo y el cristianismo.

 La victoria de Eolo

Die Zeit online sobre religiones

decadencia de Occidente, Spengler, religiones

Talk of the Decline of the West? The 75th anniversary of the death of Oswald Spengler

Coverausschnitt von `Der Untergang des Abendlandes`; © C.H. Beck VerlagTalk of the decline of the West repeatedly haunts the media. Its author, Oswald Spengler, on the other hand, seems to be forgotten. Rightly so? On the occasion of the 75th anniversary of his death on May 8, Goethe.de spoke with cultural scientist Johann Pall Arnason.J.P. Arnason is from Iceland and teaches at La Trobe University in Australia. In the spring of 2010 he was at the University of Göttingen to pursue a research project on Oswald Spengler.

Mr Arnason, Spengler’s title “The Decline of the West (Untergang des Abendlandes)” is still proverbial in German, though hardly anyone actually reads the book any more. How do you explain Spengler’s strong indirect influence?

Johann Pall Arnason; © Universität GöttingenOn the one hand, Spengler is regarded as dealt with – certainly for good reasons. On the other hand, we can’t get rid of him. There will always be moods of crisis and decline in which we remember the title of his famous book. In recent years Spengler has even been newly translated, most recently into Czech for the first time. In post-communist states it is probably the disappointment with the capitalist path taken since 1990 that has made his scepticism about civilisation seem relevant again.

Spengler should’t be left to the extreme Right

Is such a Spengler renaissance dangerous because it supplies thinkers from the extreme Right with key ideas?

Cover of `Der Untergang des Abendlandes`; © C.H. Beck VerlagThat doesn’t really play a part in the scholarly discussion. We shouldn’t eschew Spengler because he was close to the right-wing of the political spectrum.

What was Spengler’s political position?

His political position was quite complex. He didn’t write The Decline of the West as a way of coping with the German defeat in the First World War, as is often assumed abroad. He already had the idea for the book before the war, and indeed he expected a German victory. Then in the 1920s he was in fact a kind of political activist for the radical Right.

Spengler was part of the so-called “Conservative Revolution” – which wasn’t, by the way, a single movement. In the 1932 presidential election he voted for Adolph Hitler, although he didn’t like him. But Spengler wasn’t a pioneer of the Third Reich. After Hitler took power in 1933, Spengler even showed political courage by criticising him in his book The Hour of Decision. After 1934 he went into inner emigration. In his unpublished notes from these years he wrote that Germany was now governed by murderers and compared Hitler to a monkey that had been set down to play a piano.

Family resemblances

And he wasn’t read and discussed only by the Conservative Revolution?

Oswald Spengler; © Deutsches Bundesarchiv (German Federal Archive)Not at all. There are surprising connections in Spengler’s reception. In the 1930s the eminent Finnish philosopher Georg Henrik von Wright and Ludwig Wittgenstein had discussions about him. Wittgenstein’s later use of “forms of life (Lebensformen)”, in which all our language games are embedded, was clearly influenced by his reading of Spengler.

Wittgenstein thought that Spengler should have spoken of the “family resemblances” of cultural phenomena instead of quasi-organic laws. This would have freed Spengler form his own misunderstanding of cultures as self-contained entities that don’t communicate with each another. And between the wars the Icelandic Nobel laureate in literature, Halldór Kiljan Laxness, even propounded a kind of Spenglerian Marxism – that is, interpreted Spengler from a leftist point of view.

Of cultural clash and collapse

Why should we still read Spengler today?

Cover of `Kollaps: Warum Gesellschaften überleben oder untergehen` (i.e. Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed); © Fischer Taschenbuch VerlagI can think of a number of issues on which Spengler’s thought could have a stimulating effect, without having to warm up again his whole “morphology of world history”. To begin with, critically: Spengler’s idea of self-contained high cultures still haunts the comparative study of civilisations. It is certainly in the background of Samuel Huntington’s theses about the “clash of civilisations”. On the other hand, sociology concerns itself too little about cultural forms of life, not least because of its fixation on the alternative of action or system. There is a deficit. Also not understanding that art and the history of art are significant dimensions of such forms of life, something to which Spengler attached great importance.

And finally there is in current civilisation research, initiated by, for example, Jared Diamond’s well-known book Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed, a fresh discussion about collapse and failure. Here there’s no way round a critical reception of Spengler’s work.

Gregor Taxacher
conducted the interview. He is a theologian and works as an editor for West German Broadcasting (WDR) and as a freelance author (focussing on, among other subjects, Christianity, Judaism and Islam). In 2010 the Wissenschaftlichen Buchgesellschaft (WBG) published his book “Apokalyptische Vernunft: Das biblische Geschichtsdenken und seine Konsequenzen” (i.e., Apocalyptic Reason: Biblical Historical Thought and Its Consequences). He lives in Cologne.Translation: Jonathan Uhlaner
Copyright: Goethe-Institut e. V., Online-Redaktion
May 2011

Any questions about this article? Please write to us!
online-redaktion@goethe.de

Related links

links sobre religiones (Goethe Inst site)

Dialog zwischen den Religionen

Christian-Islamic Encounter and Documentation Centre (CIBEDO)   deutsch

CIBEDO is the specialist centre of the German Bishops’ Conference with the task of fostering inter-religious dialogue between Christianity and Islam as well as encouraging the coexistence of Christians and Muslims. Its home page offers information on events, literature tips and an overview of dialogue topics present in the media.

Christian-Islamic Society   deutsch

The Christian-Islamic Society (CIG) is a registered association dedicated to the promotion of understanding and dialogue between Christians and Muslims, Christian churches and Islamic societies. Its home page includes event tips and an extensive literature list on the topic of Christian-Islamic dialogue.

Coordination Council of the Associations of Christian-Islamic Dialogue   deutsch

A great variety of dialogue initiatives are represented in the Coordination Council. Its home page gives information about the individual initiatives, its events and the lobby work of the Council.

German Coordinating Council of Societies for Christian-Jewish Cooperation (DKR)   deutsch

DKR and its societies campaign for Judeo-Christian dialogue, stand up against anti-Semitism and right-wing extremism and foster a peaceful co-existence of peoples and religions. DKR’s home page offers tips regarding dialogue events, publications on the topic and information on the society’s history and work.

German-Israel Society   deutsch

The German-Israel Society sees its major task in encouraging dialogue and reconciliation between Israel and Germany as well as communicating Israel’s position and needs in Germany. Its home page contains information on events and press reports.

Global Ethic Foundation   deutschenglishespañolfrançais

The programmatic basis of the Foundation’s work is the “Declaration towards a Global Ethic” endorsed by the Parliament of the World’s Religions. According to a thesis of Hans Küng’s, a peaceful co-existence of the world religions will only be possible if they reflect on a common ethic that all of them can support.

Islam portal www.qantara.de   deutschenglishtürkçeعربي

Qantara.de sees itself as a bridge to the Islamic world and provides information and discussions on politics, culture and social life in German, Arabic, Turkish and English. Project partners are the Federal Centre for Political Education, the German international broadcasting service Deutsche Welle, Goethe Institut and the Institute for Foreign Cultural Relations.

Islam Research Directory (web project), IRD   deutschenglish

IRD forges links among institutions, experts and the media with academic interest in specific topics and countries of the Islamic and Arab world. Goethe Institut and the German Institute of Middle East Studies in Hamburg count among the partner organisations.

Jewish Museum Berlin   deutschenglish

The Jewish Museum in Berlin invites its visitors to explore two millennia of German-Jewish history.

Informationsportale

Catholic News   deutsch

Catholic News offers a wide-ranging information portal covering topical issues, discussions and news. Additionally, an interactive forum is available, as are a number of other services.

Information Platform Religion   deutsch

The Information Platform Religion is a project of the Religious Studies Media and Information Service (REMID) in Marburg and supported by the Alliance for Democracy and Tolerance and the German Federal Ministry for Family, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth. With its great variety of up-to-date articles, background texts and links it offers a broad range of information on the world religions and new religions.

Islam Online   deutsch

Islam Online gives information on communities and umbrella organisations, publishes reports on current topics from the Muslim point of view and provides information on daily Islamic life.

Münster Forum for Theology and Church   deutsch

This internet portal offers a multitude of current dossiers, texts and discussion contributions on the topics of religion and the church from a Christian-Catholic point of view. In addition it includes an extensive link list to other institutions and theological topics.

Portal of the German Buddhist Union   deutsch

This portal informs the reader about Buddhist life in Germany and Buddhist groups, Buddhism in general, literature and event tips.

Publications by Friedhelm Hengsbach   deutsch

In his publications, Friedhelm Hengsbach critically examines the changing world of work in the context of an evolving welfare state. He discusses the meaning of social justice and social equality, and asks whether a new free market-style capitalism can serve as a substitute religion in a secularized society or whether a new balance in society could be achieved by a return to Christian values.

Religious Studies Media and Information Service (REMID)   deutsch

REMID, an association of professors of Religious Studies in Marburg, provides information on the topic of religion for the media, federal institutions and the interested public. REMID organizes its own events and projects, finds positions for speakers and experts, draws up documentations and has its own publications.

talmud.de: Jewish life in Germany   deutschenglish

This page offers background information, platforms, literature and link tips on daily Jewish life.

Institutions

Catholic Church in Germany   deutsch

The web page of the Catholic Church in Germany gives background information on faith and religion, activities and events, partner organisations and comments on everyday topics.

Central Council of Jews in Germany   deutschenglishрусский

As a corporation under public law, the principal task of the Central Council of Jews in Germany is to defend the interests of its members within society as a whole. The home page includes background information on Judaism as a religion, news for community members, literature and link tips as well as articles regarding the integration of East European immigrants.

Central Council of Muslims in Germany   deutsch

The Central Council of Muslims in Germany is a leading association of the Islamic umbrella organisations in Germany. Its web page supplies information on the Central Council’s activities, tasks and objectives. Furthermore it offers a wide ranging portal for Muslim life in Germany including platforms, current news and link lists.

Centre of Research on Anti-Semitism   deutsch

The Centre of Research on Anti-Semitism, located at the Technical University of Berlin, was founded in 1982 and is the only institution of its kind for interdisciplinary research and teaching on prejudices and its consequences such as anti-Semitism, antiziganism, xenophobia and racism.

Evangelical Central Office for Questions about World Views   deutsch

The Evangelical Central Office for Questions about World Views (EZW) is the central office of the Evangelical Church in Germany (EKD) for scientific study, documentation, information and advice concerning contemporary religious and ideological trends. Its task is to monitor and assess these trends. The website contains information about the institute’s work, opinions and events.

Evangelical Church in Germany (EKD)   deutschenglishfrançais

EKD is an amalgamation of all 23 regional Evangelical churches in Germany. The home page provides information on the Protestant faith, allows an insight into religious daily life and gives theological advice. It equally portrays the official Church with its institutions and work in the parishes.

Federal Ministry of the Interior – Churches and Religious Communities   deutsch

The Website of the German Federal Ministry of the Interior provides information about the political objectives of the German Government in dealing with religious communities and Germany, and makes available data and information material about the individual groups. In addition, a detailed report is presented on the German Islam Conference.

German Bishops’ Conference   deutschenglish

The German Bishops’ Conference is an amalgamation of the bishops from all German dioceses. With its up-to-date reports, presentations of persons and competences as well as statistics, the home page gives an insight into the official Catholic Church.

International Movement “We Are Church”   deutschenglish

This movement was founded in Austria in 1995 and aims to reform the Catholic Church. “We are Church” endeavours to strengthen the concept of community life and the extent to which believers have a say in matters. Its web page provides information on the views, projects and activities of the movement.

Tibetan Centre   deutsch

The Tibetan Centre runs seminars, study courses and meditation exercises to teach about Tibetan Buddhism. In addition, it publishes information about the situation in Tibet and organizes aid programmes for Tibetan refugees and Buddhists living in Tibet.

Turkish Islamic Union for Religious Affairs (DITIB)   deutschtürkçe

The Turkish Islamic Union for Religious Affairs Reg. Assoc. aims to support the religious practice and social and cultural integration of its members thanks to voluntary involvement. The web page provides information on Islam, events and contains a presentation of the Union’s publications.

World Council of Churches   deutsch

The World Council of Churches is an amalgamation of 340 churches worldwide and serves as a communication platform with the goal of Christian unity. The web page gives an insight into the organisation and the objectives of the ecumenical World Council of Churches. In addition it includes current news, literature and link tips as well as multimedia documentations on the topic.

Religious Research

Centre for Modern Oriental Studies (ZMO)   deutschenglishfrançaisعربي

ZMO was established in 1996 as a non-university Humanities centre working in the field of historical cultural and social sciences. The Centre’s funding provider is the Society of Humanities Centres in Berlin. ZMO’s research focuses on Islamic societies in the Middle East, Africa and South and South-East Asia.

Centre for Religious Studies (CRS)   deutsch

The CRS was established in 2002 by the Westphalian Wilhelms University in Münster in co-operation with the Ministry of Schools, Science and Research. The Centre for Religious Studies is tasked with setting a framework for religious studies, primarily in the fields of Islam, Orthodox Christianity and Judaism. In particular, it develops courses to qualify teachers to give Orthodox and Islamic religious instruction at state schools.

German Liturgical Institute   deutsch

The German Liturgical Institute is a centre of work and studies with the task of promoting the church service of the Catholic Church in Germany and the German-speaking area. The institute sees itself acting in the capacity as an interface between academic theology and liturgical practice, and between church institutions and parishes.

German National Ethics Council   deutschenglishfrançais

Following the Federal Government’s decision of 2 May 2001, the National Ethics Council was set up on 8 June 2001 as a national forum for dialogue on ethical issues in the life sciences. It is intended to be the central organ for interdisciplinary discourse between Natural Sciences, Medicine, Theology and Philosophy, and the social and legal sciences, and to express views on ethical issues relating to new developments in the field of life sciences and on their consequences for the individual and society.

German Society of Religious Philosophy   deutsch

The German Society of Religious Philosophy was founded in 1999 as a non-profit-making organization. The Society’s objective is to promote and intensify research and discussion on philosophy of religion in the German-speaking world. It does not represent a certain doctrine but interprets religious philosophy as a critical philosophic debate about all factual issues, questions of meaning and importance with regard to the sphere of religions.

GIGA – German Institute for Middle East Studies (DOI)   deutschenglish

The German Institute for Middle East Studies is a non-university, publicly funded research institute which focuses on the contemporary political, economic and social developments in the North African and Middle East regions.

Institute for the Research of Contemporary Religious Culture (IrG)   deutschenglish

Founded in 1996, the Institute for the Research of Contemporary Religious Culture (IrG) sees itself in the role of contributing towards the analysis of contemporary religious culture via interdisciplinary co-operation.

Interdisciplinary Forum on Religion (IFR)   deutsch

The Interdisciplinary Forum on Religion (IFR) was founded in 2004 and is a central institution of the University of Erfurt comprising some 30 professors and 65 young academics from all faculties of the university and from the Max Weber Centre.

Max Weber Centre for Advanced Cultural and Social Studies  deutschenglish

Teaching and research at the Max Weber Centre began in 1998. It is a faculty-like central institution of the University of Erfurt where research and teaching is conducted in the following subjects: Sociology, Philosophy, Religious Studies, Law, Economics and History.

Youth and Church Research Unit   deutsch

The Youth and Church Research Unit is affiliated to the Chair for Practical Theology of the Ludwig Maximilian University in Munich. The work of the Youth and Research Unit aims to describe the basic conditions in which the youth of today live and to apply them to the relationship between young people and church and religion.

Events and Projects

German Protestant Kirchentag (Church Day)   deutschenglishfrançais

For five days around 100,000 Protestant lay Christians from all over Germany will be gathering at the German Protestant Kirchentag in order to discuss anew their role as Christians in encounters with representatives from the world of politics, the economy, culture, from the official Church, and with artists and intellectuals.

2010 Ecumenical Church Day   deutsch

Following the first Ecumenical Church Day in Berlin in 2003, Christians of different denominations will be meeting again in Munich in 2010 to jointly profess their faith and, through encounters and discussions, define their responsibility for the future of the Church and the world.

Joint Statement on the Social and Economic Situation by Churches in Germany   deutschenglishfrançais

Ten years ago, the two main churches in Germany published a joint statement on the social and economic situation. In this statement, they rejected the liberal market tendencies in Germany and called for the Federal Government of the time to initiate far-reaching reforms. The website contains the original statement and a review of the developments of the past ten years.

“Mosque Open Day”   deutsch

Every year on 3rd October up to 1000 mosques all over Germany open their gates to mark “Mosque Open Day”. With mosque tours, podium discussions, exhibitions, bookstalls and traditional events, the mosque communities seek to make contact with their fellow citizens.

World Youth Day   deutsch

The World Youth Day unites young Catholics from all over the world who wish to experience their faith with others. The web page has information on the objectives and the organization of the World Youth Day and reports on future World Youth Days and the present state of the preparations.

investigación en Alemania sobre religiones

Brief Résumée

Prof. Dr. Michael von Brück studied at the Universities of Rostock, Bangalore and Madras. His areas of specialisation include Hinduism, Buddhism, Tibetan Buddhism, and the History and Hermeneutics of Inter-Religious Dialogue, on which he has published numerous writings. In addition to Guest Professorships in India, the U.S.A. and Germany, he was Professor for Comparative Religion at the University of Regensburg from 1988-1991. Since 1991, he has been Professor of Religious Studies and Head of the Inter-Faculty Course of Study in Religious Studies at the University of Munich.
doppelter Rechts-Pfeil Plea for a Politics of Inter-Religious Dialogue Deutsche Flagge Englische Flagge
doppelter Rechts-Pfeil Religions Today Deutsche Flagge Englische Flagge
Prof. Dr. Friedrich Wilhelm Graf; Copyright: Institut für Systematische Theologie/Friedrich Wilhel Graf Friedrich Wilhelm Graf, PhD. In theology, was born in 1948 in Wuppertal, germany. He studied Protestant theology, philosophy and history at the universities of Wuppertal, Tübingen and Munich, and has been Professor for systematic Theology and ethics at the Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität in Munich since 1999. In 1999 he was awarded the Leibniz Prize of the German Association of Higher Studies (Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft), the first theologian to receive this award. Prof. Graf is a regular member of the Bavarian Academy of Sciences (Bayerische Akademie der Wissenschaften). In 2006/2007 Friedrich Wilhelm Graf is at the Institute for Advanced study in Berlin.
doppelter Rechts-Pfeil Friedrich Wilhelm Graf on the Challenge of the Religions Deutsche Flagge Englische Flagge
Lamya Kaddor Lamya Kaddor, M.A., is the academic assistant at Germany’s first university chair for the religion of Islam at the Centre for Religious Studies of the University of Münster. She is working as a teacher as part of North-Rhine/Westphalia’s trial phase of “Islamic studies in German”, and is writing a doctoral thesis on “Blood and its significance in Islam” in the field of Islamic theology. Since the 2006/2007 school year, she has been offering further training on behalf of the Culture Ministry of Lower Saxony in the field of “Theory of Islamic Religious Instruction and Theology”.
doppelter Rechts-Pfeil Classes in Islamic Religion and Studies at German Schools Deutsche Flagge Englische Flagge
Hubert Knoblauch, born in 1959. Professor of General Sociology at the Technical University Berlin. 2000 – 2002 Professor of Religious Sociology at the Zurich University. Focal areas: sociology of knowledge, religious sociology, communication, qualitative methods. Most recent publications:Religionssoziologie. Berlin/ New York 1999;Berichte aus dem Jenseits. Mythos und Realität der Nahtoderfahrung. Freiburg 1999;Qualitative Religionsforschung. Paderborn 2003; Wissenssoziologie. Konstanz 2005.Homepage
Professor Claus Leggewie (*1950), professor at the Institute for Political Science at Giessen’s Justus-Liebig University since 1989, founding director of the Centre for Media and Interactivity at the university, project leader in the German Research Foundation’s collaborative research centre «Memory Cultures» and co-head of the German Research Foundation’s Research Training Group «Transnational Media Events». Max Weber Chair at New York University from 1995 to 1997, fellow at the Institute for Human Sciences in Vienna in 1994 and 2006, fellow at the Berlin Institute for Advanced Study in 1999/2000, and director of the Cultural Science Institute in Essen from 2007.
doppelter Rechts-Pfeil Religions and Globalisation Deutsche Flagge Englische Flagge
doppelter Rechts-Pfeil Claus Leggewie – Herald of Social ChangeDeutsche Flagge Englische Flagge
Foto: Detlef Pollack, Copyright: privat Detlef Pollack, is a professor for comparative social and cultural studies at the European University Viadrina in Frankfurt (Oder). In 1997 he was a Fellow of theWissenschaftskolleg (Institute for Advanced Study) in Berlin and in 2003 he held the Max Weber Chair at New York University. His research focuses on the sociology of religion, political cultural research, new social movements and system theory. Homepage

estudios sobre religiones, sitio del Goethe Institut

Rabbi students and rabbi at the annual conference of the Union of Progressive Jews in Berlin, preparing for the service; © Tobias Barniske

Reform Judaism in Germany: A Renaissance

In recent years, immigration has led to a more than six-fold increase in the number of Jews in Germany. For the first time since the Second World War, Liberal Judaism is once again becoming established in the land of the Holocaust, creating a link to a destroyed tradition.More …
Copyright: picture-alliance / OKAPIA KG, Germany

Noah’s Arc or the Beagle? Creationism, the Theory of Evolution, and Education

Criticism of the theory of evolution is nothing new. By Christoph LammersMore …
Gebetswand; Copyright: www.pixelquelle.de

A discussion between Hubert Knoblauch (from the Technical University of Berlin) and Detlef Pollack (from the University Viadrina in Frankfurt an der Oder) about the supposed return of religion

Is religion enjoying a renaissance? The two sociologists of religion are at variance with each other. Interview conducted by: Jürgen KaubeMore …

Religions Today

The interpenetration of diverse religions connected with globalisation is leading to the pluralization of life styles. By Michael von BrückMore …
Boris Groys: Medium as Religion (2006); © Boris Groys

“We’re On the Way to Designing Religion”

The Internet has placed the religions of the Book before perhaps the greatest change in their history. This may be seen at an exhibition in Karlsruhe. An interview with curator Boris Groys on the faith in the omnipotence of images, medial culture wars, and TV broadcasts’ sense of mission.More …
Pope benedict XVI greeting children in Rome; Copyright: picture-alliance/ dpa

Faith and Certainty

Pope Benedict XVI.

In spite of all his intellectual brilliance, the theology of Pope Benedict XVI cannot be explained without the heartwarming Catholicism of his Bavarian homeland. By Matthias DrobinskiMore …

Spirituality in Modern Singapore (GI Singapore)

Foto/Copyright: Fiona KohYoung photo artists from Singapore dealt with this topic in a workshop run by Beat Presser.
 Slide Show Selected Photos
 The Project
The poster shows five leaders of major religious communities expressing their conviction that the peaceful cohabitation of different nationalities, cultures and religious communities in Berlin has long since become reality. Copyright: picture-alliance/ ZB

Plea for a Politics of Inter-Religious Dialogue

The present conflicts of religion can hardly be understood under the vague concept of a ‘Clash of Civilisations’, and are rather the expression of a loss of identity and power.By Michael von BrückMore …
Hans Belting `Florenz und Bagdad´; Copyright: Verlag C.H. Beck oHG

Getting the Picture about the Power of Seeing: Hans Belting Writes a West-Eastern History of Vision

In his most recent study, Hans Belting, a German art historian and image theorist, has produced a milestone work on the cultural history of perspective – a history that he has put through a thorough-going revision and expanded to include its Arabic influences.More …

filosofía y religión

Powerless Philosophy? – A debate in the Magazine “Merkur”

© Colourbox.comWhat influence do philosophers still have in our expert-dominated society? Recently Karl Heinz Bohrer and Volker Gerhardt have broached a debate in Merkur, the “German Journal for European Thought”, on what relevance philosophy still has today.In the issue of Merkur published in autumn 2010, Karl Heinz Bohrer addressed a finding that could be a cause of concern in the land of poets and thinkers: Philosophy and the systematic ideas it has formulated have, since the end of the 1970s at the latest, dramatically lost in influence. Where, asks Bohrer, are the great names and the great ideas that command the attention of the times? The post-modern diagnosis of the end of “meta-narratives” seems to have come true. Of philosophy is left only a specialised subject at universities and philosophical essay writing that, though very stimulating, is no longer systematically comprehensive.

If in his reply to this Volker Gerhardt points, not without good reason, to the booming field of Applied Ethics and to the participation of philosophers in ethics boards, that does not address Bohrer’s basic diagnosis. Philosophy certainly does not exercise “power”, even if some of the key principles of the Enlightenment tradition have long found expression in the opinions of the high courts – and so first of all gained real meaning. It is another question of course whether philosophy ever had more “power” than this. Above all, it is doubtful whether the question of influence or even usefulness can arrive at a just appreciation philosophy at all.

End in itself or means to an end?

Aristoteles; © Lorenz ViereckeIt has been part of the philosophy’s understanding of itself from time immemorial that it distances itself from the expectation of providing direct social benefit. Philosophical knowledge has always been an end in itself. Philosophy is desirable for man for its own sake. It is quite in this sense that Gerhardt defends philosophy: “If philosophy were really to confine itself to its ‘social relevance’, then we could safely dispense with it”. For Bohrer, the same applies to the utilisation of philosophy in ethic boards: “A philosophy that has settled into practice or would influence practice forfeits its specifically philosophical character”.

Only by insisting on its independence can philosophy maintain its spirit of contradiction and resist instrumentalisation of any kind. And only then can it be inspiring and “useful” for a free society and its critical public. This need hardly mean, however, that philosophy shut itself up from the outset in an ivory tower standing far above practice. On the contrary, Gerhardt rightly observes that “Lack of interest in social relevance is hardly a mark of quality in philosophy”. Not Plato’s metaphysical contemplation of the Ideas, but rather the practical philosophy of Aristotle would accordingly provide the bearings for independent thought that does not feel itself above a concern for social practice.

Open, democratic societies have no need of philosopher-kings

John Rawls; © Lorenz ViereckeAgainst this background, Gerhardt then, quite logically and in the Aristotelian spirit, sings the praises of the diversity of philosophy. Especially in post-metaphysical modernity, with its pronounced social pluralism, there is no longer room for the great systems and projects. Open, democratic societies have no need of philosopher-kings. Making do pragmatically in social practice with the penultimate and the preliminary is quite a civilised achievement. It is therefore not surprising that in his conclusion Bohrer sees in the American liberal John Rawls the philosopher whose work is today “of the highest philosophical-theoretical relevance and, at the same time, of tremendous public significance”. Rawl’s concept of fairness is essential to the political-philosophical self-understanding of pluralist democracies.

For all other, sometimes existentially important questions, notoriously insecure modern man has a great deal of competing answers. Here philosophy, alone because of its long tradition, has much to offer. It does not have a monopoly of interpretation, nor much appreciable “power”; but it does not need these in order to exercise its inspiring influence.

Christian Schwaabe
Since completing his post-doctoral qualification, the writer has been a lecturer in Political Philosophy at the University of Munich and author of several works, including the two-volume textbook Politische Theorie (UTB, 2nd ed., 2010).Translation: Jonathan Uhlaner
Copyright: Goethe-Institut e. V., Online-Redaktion
March 2011

Any questions about this article? Please write to us!
online-redaktion@goethe.de

Related links

globalización y religionmes

Design for the construction of a new mosque in Cologne; Copyright: picture-alliance/ dpa

New Mosques in Germany – A Sign of Progress towards Integration

„Building mosques is an important step towards integrating Islam in Germany,“ states the „Provisional Report of the Study and Discussion Groups“ of the German Conference on Islam, issued in March 2008.More …
Cover `Gewals als Gottesdienst´; Copyright: C. H. Beck Verlag

Religious Violence in the Age of Globalization

Apparently violence and religion are entering into an unholy alliance with each other more and more often. Hans G. Kippenberg, an expert in comparative religion, investigates the interplay of sociopolitical conflicts and religious convictions in the age of globalization.More …
Yavuz Sultan Selim Mosque in Mannheim; Copyright: picture-alliance/ dpa

«A Central Human Right is at Issue here»

A conversation with Konrad Hilpert, Professor of Moral Theology at the University of Munich, on freedom of religion in an altered religious landscape and the need to restructure the relationship between state and religion. Interview: Matthias Drobinski. More …
31. Protestant Church Convention in Cologne; Copyright: picture-alliance/ dpa

What Effects is the Globalization of Religions having on German Society?

The globalization of the religions has highlighted religion in the public and media in new ways. By Detlef PollackMore …
There is a file of teaching materials with the word Allah written in Arabic on the front lying on a table in a classroom in Hanover. Teacher Tünay Özrecber is teaching Islam to a third-grade class at the Salzmannstrasse elementary school. Whilst some of the Länder are still arguing about whether to introduce the subject or not, it has already been taught in Lower Saxony for a year and a half. Copyright: picture-alliance/ dpa/dpaweb

Classes in Islamic Religion and Studies at German Schools

Trial lessons are being held in many of Germany’s Länder. But «Islamic Religion» is still not being provided as a standard part of the curriculum in Germany.
By Lamya KaddorMore …
Professor Richard Schröder; Copyright: Nationaler Ethikrat

Religion and Violence

A religiously motivated willingness to make use of violence is confronting the world with challenges that were unknown before September 11, 2001. Politics seems to depend on a discourse encompassing all aspects of society to be able to provide solutions. Goethe.de spoke with Professor Richard Schröder of the Nationaler Ethikrat (i.e. National Council on Ethics) on the the potential for violence in religions. Volker Maria Neumann conducted the interviewMore …
Sign in front of the Fatih mosque in Essen showing times of christian church servives. Copyright: picture-alliance/ dpa

Religions and Globalisation

The integration of non-Christian religious communities, not only Muslims, requires a readjustment of the relationship between religion and politics in Germany and in the European Union. By Claus LeggewieMore …

¿renacen las religiones?

Mosque in Duisburg’s Marxloh district; © DITIB Begegnungsstätte

Getting Along Just Fine in Duisburg-Marxloh – Germany’s Biggest Mosque

In Cologne the plan to build a mosque has not only provoked demonstrations and counter demonstrations, but books on the issue have been published and there have been all kinds of public debate in the press. On the other hand Germany’s biggest mosque was opened in Marxloh, Duisburg, in October 2008 – with no fuss at all.More …
Copyright: www.colourbox.com

The Relationship between Faith and Science

„I only believe what I see“ was the title of a project by the Protestant Students’ Association of the Technical University of Braunschweig to illuminate the occasionally problematic relationship between religion and science.More …
Peter Sloterdijk `Gottes Eifer. Vom Kampf der drei Monotheismen´; Copyright: Suhrkamp-Verlag

Competing Monotheisms

One hears a lot these days about a renaissance of religion, and much about religious fanatics, too. In his most recent essay, Gottes Eifer. Vom Kampf der drei Monotheismen (i.e. the zealous God: on the struggle of the three monotheisms), Peter Sloterdijk, a philosopher and cultural commentator, explores the questions about the sources of the strength of the belief in one God, and what effects it has on its adherents.More …
Copyright: picture-alliance / Godong

The Study „Youth in Europe“ Reveals that Europe’s Young People Are less Secular-minded than has been Generally Assumed

What influence does religion have on the way young people shape their lives? By Michael BirgdenMore …
Pope Benedict XVI on his arrival at St Pantaleon's Church in Cologne at World Youth Day 2005; Copyright: picture-alliance/ dpa/dpaweb

The Future of Christianity

It is a risky undertaking for a scientist or scholar to talk about the future. (…) One prognosis about the future of religion stood almost unchallenged in academia and in public opinion until a few years ago. By Hans JoasMore …

Verlag der Weltreligionen – Greater Education Potential

Under the roof of the publishing house Suhrkamp Verlag in Frankfurt-am-Main, a new publishing house for world religions has been set up: Verlag der Weltreligionen. The launch programme indicates an enlightened project, namely religion as world literature. The first volumes are already available.More …
Professor Dr Friedrich Wilhelm Graf; Copyright: Institut für Systematische Theologie/Friedrich Wilhel Graf

Friedrich Wilhelm Graf on the Challenge of the Religions

A conversation with a theologian on the reemergence, crisis and mutual competition of the religions, secularization and resacralization, as well as changes in the religious landscape both in Germany and world-wide. An Interview by: Matthias DrobinskiMore …
Copyright: Colourbox

Where God Lives – Brain Research and Religion

What happens when we pray, meditate, or engage in other religious activities? Neuroscientists are using imaging techniques to shed light on what our grey cells get up to in such cases. Does God exist only in our minds? By Ulrich Kraft

budismo y religión

Vajramala (Sabine Thielow) became Director of the Buddhist study and meditation center «Mahakala Ashram,» on the shores of Lake Constance, in 1991 and has been Chairperson of the German Buddhist Union (Deutsche Buddhistische Union, DBU) since 2001. 

  1. What do I expect of my religion?In his teachings, the Buddha warned his disciples about harboring expectations, since our view of the world is colored by our expectations. What I in fact want is to recognize reality as it is and overcome my illusions that are always generating new problems, step by step. Like all beings, I yearn for an everlasting happiness, a happiness that does not bear the seed of future suffering within itself. Through the methods that the Buddha and his realized disciples taught for going on this path, a follower of the Buddha can develop an ever-more comprehensive view, and thus not only attain deeper insight, but also gain understanding and compassion for the suffering of living beings.
  2. What does my religion expect of me?The Buddha taught his disciples to tame the mind through the practice of mindfulness in thought, word and deed, to enable them to gain an increasingly clear understanding of the consequences of their actions and thereby develop an outlook of causing no harm. He showed them effective methods for practicing positive, beneficial conduct and for training the mind, methods that ultimately lead to the development of all-encompassing compassion and deeper wisdom.
  3. How much religious diversity can society cope with?A country like India has demonstrated in its past that a peaceful coexistence of many religions is not only possible but can also lead to the flowering of culture. It is high time that the religions cooperatively engage themselves for peace, kindness and solidarity, and the well-being of human beings, animals and nature, and work together on the basis of mutual appreciation for the benefit of all. The variety of authentic religious paths could enrich people in all their diversity, and open up a path to every seeker that is suited to him.
  4. Are we seeing a renaissance of the religions?We are living a time of insecurity, and therefore people are asking more about the meaning of their lives. Religions can give them answers.
  5. A question for the other religions…Why do some representatives of monotheistic religions still insist that they are in possession of the one valid truth? In a country where members of many different religions live together, it would make sense to follow the advice of the Buddhist Emperor Ashoka not just to listen to the opinions of others, but to do so gladly.

Anteriores Entradas antiguas